Book Hotels in Shelter Island, USA
Find your next stay with 2,200,000+ Hotels, Homes, Apartments & Villas
December 2025
Dec 2025
MonTueWedThuFriSatSun
Jan 2026
MonTueWedThuFriSatSun
Wednesday 31 December 2025 - Thursday 01 January 2026 (1 night)
31 Dec 2025
Wednesday
01 Jan 2026
Thursday
2 Adults - 0 Child
1 room
Shelter Island - 3 Hotels to Choose From
Find deals where other travellers are staying
See map view
Best Price Guarantee
We guarantee we won't be beaten on price. If you find a cheaper hotel deal on another website after you book with us, we’ll refund the difference!
Sort by:
See the latest prices and deals by choosing your dates. Choose dates
Sunset Beach Hotel
35 Shore Rd, Shelter Island, USA - See map
AmenitiesSandpoint by Rove Travel Modern 5BR w Pool
13 Brander Pkwy Shelter Island NY 11964 USA, Shelter Island, USA - See map
Amenities
2% giveback on bookings
Create an account or login to unlock these rewards
Continue Your Adventure
- All Cities in the USA
- Explore More Hotels
Inspiration
Where To Go & What To See
Get inspired with travel guides and destination ideas from our blog
Explore Our Travel Guides
- Travel Planning
- CRYPTO
- Travel Destination
- Accommodation Guides
- Travel Trends
- News
- 15 Travel Hacks for Long Trips | Stay Comfortable & Stress-Free
- Travel Refund Delays: How Long Airlines & Hotels Really Take to Pay You Back
- The 10 Best Solo Female Travel Destinations for Safety, Adventure, and Empowerment
- The Best Cryptocurrencies for Travelers to Buy and Use in 2025
- Travel Tips for First-Time Flyers: Everything You Need to Know Before Your First Trip
- Season of the Skies: When Air Travel Peaks Around the World
- The Price of a Hotel Room Around the World
- Airline Cancellations: The Worst Offenders & How to Get a Refund
- When Is the Best Time to Book Flights in 2025? (Data-Driven Guide)
- How to Plan the Perfect Workation: Work Remotely While Exploring the World
- Best Budget Travel Destinations for 2025: Adventure Without Breaking the Bank
- Best Places to Travel in December on a Budget
- Travala.com Introduces Zero-Fee Ethereum Travel Bookings
- Discovering the Safest Countries in Asia: Your Ultimate Guide
- Malaysia Digital Nomad Visa Guide
- Book Travel With USDC: The Ultimate Guide
- Book Travel With USDT: The Ultimate Guide
- Book Travel With TUSD: The Ultimate Guide
- Travala.com Enables Zero-fee Bitcoin Travel Bookings
- Bali’s New Rules for Tourists: What You Need to Know
- Hotels that Accept Crypto: A New Era in Hospitality
- How to Pay for Flights with Cryptocurrencies
- FLEXIROAM PARTNERS WITH TRAVALA.COM
- Get up to 15% Back on Travel Bookings to Binance Blockchain Week Dubai 2025 with Binance Pay
- The Best Cryptocurrencies for Travelers to Buy and Use in 2025
- Crypto Travel Rule 2025: Booking Trips with Digital Currency
- What makes crypto customers 3 times more valuable?
- Where Cryptocurrency Is Banned: Countries You Should Know Before You Travel
- Crypto Tax Report 2025: How Much You’ll Pay Depending on Where You Live
- The Ultimate Guide to Crypto Wallets: Types, AI Innovations & Top Hardware Picks for 2025
- Travelling with Crypto in Argentina: Impact of VASP Rules in 2025
- Best Cold Wallets for Crypto: Safely Store Your Digital Assets
- Building & Securing Crypto Exchanges: Key Challenges, Regulations, and Cold Storage Solutions
- Trump Coin and the Future of Political Cryptocurrencies: What Travellers Should Know
- The Smart Guide to Crypto in 2025
- Travala.com and Galxe Announce Collaboration with $10,000 in Prizes
- Travala.com Awarded RMA™ Certification from VaaSBlock
- Travala.com Announces Solana Integration and SOL Travel Rewards
- Travel to Binance Blockchain Week Dubai 2024 with Binance Pay & Get up to 10% Back in Travel Credits
- Travala.com Introduces Zero-Fee Ethereum Travel Bookings
- Travala.com Partners with Toncoin to Integrate TON
- Travel to TOKEN2049 Dubai with Binance Pay & Get up to 10% Back in Travel Credits
- Book Travel With USDC: The Ultimate Guide
- 15 Travel Hacks for Long Trips | Stay Comfortable & Stress-Free
- Travel Refund Delays: How Long Airlines & Hotels Really Take to Pay You Back
- Discover Top Hotels & Activities in Buenos Aires
- The 10 Best Solo Female Travel Destinations for Safety, Adventure, and Empowerment
- Travel Tips for First-Time Flyers: Everything You Need to Know Before Your First Trip
- Discover Top Hotels & Activities in Singapore
- Season of the Skies: When Air Travel Peaks Around the World
- 7 Incredible Luxury Treehouse Hotels Around the World
- Top 10 Fall Travel Destinations: Cozy, Colorful, and Crowd-Free
- The World’s Best Hotels: A Big Data Breakdown
- The Price of a Hotel Room Around the World
- Airline Cancellations: The Worst Offenders & How to Get a Refund
- Discover Top Hotels & Activities in Seoul
- When Is the Best Time to Book Flights in 2025? (Data-Driven Guide)
- Discover Top Hotels & Activities in Bali
- Discover Top Hotels & Activities in New York
- Discover Top Hotels & Activities in Barcelona
- Discover Top Hotels & Activities in Istanbul
- Austria: Your Ultimate Travel Guide 2025
- Switzerland: Your Ultimate Travel Guide 2025
- Discover Top Hotels & Activities in Amsterdam
- Romantic Getaway Hotels Perfect for Couples: From Beachfront Suites to Cozy Mountain Cabins
- Travel Tiger Club Experience Drop #15: Luxury Kenya Travel Drop
- Hotel Spotlight | Fairmont Hotels & Resorts
- 7 Incredible Luxury Treehouse Hotels Around the World
- The World’s Best Hotels: A Big Data Breakdown
- Hotel Spotlight | Conrad Hotels by Hilton
- Top Luxury Pet-Friendly Hotels Where You and Your Pet Can Travel in Style
- Travel Tiger Club Experience Drop #14: Luxury Canada Travel Drop
- Hotel Spotlight | InterContinental Hotels by IHG
- 10 Best Beach Resorts for Families in 2025
- Travel Tiger Club Experience Drop #13: Luxury Fiji Travel Drop
- Hotel Spotlight | JW Marriott Hotels
- Travala’s Concierge Program Joins Accor Preferred Program
- Travala’s Concierge Program Joins Marriott STARS & Luminous
- Travala’s Concierge Program Joins BRAVOS by Meliá Hotels International
- Unwind at Paris Hotels With Balcony Retreats
- Explore the Best Family Hotels in Barcelona and Create Lasting Memories
- Explore the Best Boutique Hotels in Paris
- Dive Into the Best Hotel Pools in Dubai
- The Best Hotel Chains Around the World
- Travel Refund Delays: How Long Airlines & Hotels Really Take to Pay You Back
- Bleisure Travel: How to Combine Work and Play on Your Trip
- The 10 Best Solo Female Travel Destinations for Safety, Adventure, and Empowerment
- The Best Cryptocurrencies for Travelers to Buy and Use in 2025
- King Charles and Sustainable Travel: What His Initiatives Mean for the Future of Tourism
- Season of the Skies: When Air Travel Peaks Around the World
- 7 Incredible Luxury Treehouse Hotels Around the World
- Top 10 Fall Travel Destinations: Cozy, Colorful, and Crowd-Free
- What makes crypto customers 3 times more valuable?
- The World’s Best Hotels: A Big Data Breakdown
- The Price of a Hotel Room Around the World
- The State of Corporate Travel in 2025
- Airline Cancellations: The Worst Offenders & How to Get a Refund
- The Ultimate Guide to Crypto Wallets: Types, AI Innovations & Top Hardware Picks for 2025
- Travala & Binance Pay Study Reveals a New Era of High-Value Crypto Travellers
- Malaysia Digital Nomad Visa Guide
- Book Travel With USDC: The Ultimate Guide
- Book Travel With USDT: The Ultimate Guide
- Book Travel With TUSD: The Ultimate Guide
- Hotels that Accept Crypto: A New Era in Hospitality
- VIETNAM VISA GUIDE
- Travel Securely in the Web3 Era: A Practical Guide for Travala Users
- Upcoming Crypto & Travel Events: December 2025
- Travala Monthly Report: October 2025
- Get up to 15% Back on Travel Bookings to Binance Blockchain Week Dubai 2025 with Binance Pay
- Travel Tiger Club Experience Drop #15: Luxury Kenya Travel Drop
- Upcoming Crypto & Travel Events: November 2025
- Travala Quarterly Business Update: Q3 2025
- Travala Monthly Report: September 2025
- Unlock $50 Off Your Travel for Plan B Forum Lugano 2025
- What makes crypto customers 3 times more valuable?
- The Ultimate Guide to Crypto Wallets: Types, AI Innovations & Top Hardware Picks for 2025
- Best Cold Wallets for Crypto: Safely Store Your Digital Assets
FAQs
More Ways to Explore Shelter Island, the USA
See what else the USA has to offer
Type of Accommodation in Shelter Island, the USA
Budget Options in Shelter Island, the USA
Why Book Your Trip With Travala?
24/7 Customer Support
Contact our support team anytime via live chat or email
Multi-payment Options
Book with credit/debit cards and other popular methods
Rewards & Discounts
Get rewards and discounts with the AVA Smart Program
Best Price Guarantee
If you find a cheaper hotel deal, we’ll refund the difference!
Customer Reviews
What our customers say
Crypto-friendly Bookings
Your money’s good here.
Loading...